21
Wednesday
February 2018
2:42 PM IST
News Headlines
Home   | Main News   | Kerala  | National   | International  | Business   | Sports   | Entertainment   | Columns   | Offbeat   | About Deepika 
Kerala News
SC calls triple talaq the 'worst form' of ending a marriage
 
(New Delhi, May 13, 2017): Triple talaq is the "worst" and "not a desirable" form of dissolution of marriage among the Muslims, even though there were schools of thought which called it "legal", the Supreme Court observed today.

The second day of the day-long hearing on the matter also saw two veterans, jurist Ram Jethmalani and former Union Minister and Islamic scholar Arif Mohammad Khan, coming out all guns blazing against the practice of triple talaq.

A five-judge constitution bench headed by Chief Justice J S Khehar said there are "school of thoughts (which) say that triple talaq is legal, but it is the worst and not a desirable form for dissolution of marriages among Muslims."

The remark was made by the bench when senior lawyer Salman Khurshid referred to the various schools of thought and the stand of All India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB) that triple talaq was "abhorrent", yet valid.

While Jethmalani attacked the practice on various constitutional grounds including the right to equality and termed it "abhorrent", Khan said it was akin to the pre- Islamic era practice of burying a female child alive in the Arabian region.

Khan, who had quit Rajiv Gandhi's cabinet over differences in handling the Shah Bano case, was at his best while representing All India Muslim Women Personal Law Board.

He said the whole Shariat law has been distorted as "Shariat is the Holy Quran and not the opinion of these people (clerics). The Holy Quran considers the importance of family and it provides four steps before pronouncement of divorce."

"Triple talaq is far from being fundamental and very far from being sacramental to Islam. It violates every good thing which Islam prescribes. What we are seeing in the form of triple talaq is similar to the pre-Islamic era practice where female infants were buried alive," Khan told the bench which also comprised Justices Kurian Joseph, R F Nariman, U U Lalit and Abdul Nazeer.

Marriage is the only aspect which is extensively dealt in holy Quran that lays down the procedure for divorce, and various schools of thought have distorted the tenets of the holy book "to their liking", he said.

"Everything you need is in the Quran. If you need more, then look at the life of the Prophet and if you still need more, then use your own good sense," he said.

"We can change the law, but not the habits of the society. Untouchability was banished by the Constitution, but it stays with us," Khan said.

Jethmalani said "the right of triple talaq is available only to the husband and not to the wife and it breaches the Article 14 (Right to Equality) of the Constitution."

"There is no saving grace for this method of granting divorce. One-sided termination of marriage is abhorrent and avoidable," he said, adding that Article 15 of the Constitution prohibited discrimination on the grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth.

It is a settled proposition that a law can be made to improve the situation of women and not to deprive them of their rights, he said.

The bench intervened and said it was not dealing with the state laws, but rather discussing personal law.

Jethmalani said triple talaq was a discrimination on the ground of sex and this practice was abhorrent to the tenets of holy Quran and no amount of advocacy can save this "sinful" practice which is contrary to constitutional tenets.

How can a woman be allowed to become ex-wife only because her husband wants and this is "the highest kind of unconstitutional behaviour", the noted jurist said.

He said that all laws have to be in conformity of the constitutional provisions and the pre-Independece era Act on Muslim marriage has to be made applicable to all Muslims, irrespective of sects.

The bench then said that the law cannot be made applicable to all sects of Muslims and observed: "Can Hanafi law be made applicable to Shias. The answer is 'no'".

Jethmalani then referred to the constitutional provisions, saying the state shall endeavour to make the Uniform Civil Code (UCC) and the present issue should be considered in that light.

He said there were political differences in achieving UCC but while dealing with the issue of husband and wife, the court should keep the constitutional scheme in mind. (PTI)


Man jumps before lion at Thiruvananthapuram zoo
UDF members boycott peace meet at Kannur
FIR against Priya: Supreme Court stays proceedings
'Kudumbashree' to foray into e-commerce
Pandalam woman jumps to death from hospital building
SC to hear tomorrow actress Priya Varrier's plea
Shuhaib murder: Police find crucial lead
TP murder accused killed Shuhaib too, says Sudhakaran
Private bus strike called off in Kerala
Shuhaib murder: Party leaders begin fast
Robots to soon clean up manholes in State
Private bus strike: KSRTC emerges winner, collects crores
Policeman found hanging
Shuhaib's murder: Six in police custody
Cracker factory accident at Pathanamthitta: 2 dead
Actress attack case: Search to locate mobile and memory card stopped
Vice President cautions against mixing religion and politics
Nine year old falls victim to accidental strangulation
Christian Priest accused of rape in Kaduthuruthy
Husband murders wife, ends life at Irinjalakkuda
ENTERTAINMENT NEWS
New poster of Irrfan Khan Starrer 'Blackmail released
 (Feb 17, 2018): After receiving an incredible response on the teaser of the film, the makers  
Justin Bieber to take part in NBA celebrity game
Trailer of 'Pari' out !
Filmmaker Sajid Nadiadwala gets honoured by Italian Consulate
INTERNATIONAL NEWS
Trump backs ban on 'bump stocks' on semi-automatic weapons
 (New York, Feb 21, 2018): Faced with an outpouring of grief and anger over a deadly school sh
Death toll crosses 200 as Syria regime pounds rebel enclave, sends fighters to face Turkey
Japan plan to build world's tallest wooden skyscraper
Nepal's two Communist parties decide to merge
NATIONAL NEWS
Not much political space for Haasan's party in TN: Moily
 (Hyderabad, Feb 21, 2018): Senior Congress leader M Veerappa Moily today said that veteran ac
SC allows Centre to withdraw force from Darjeeling hills
CBI begins questioning of Rotomac owner Kothari
Kamal Haasan visits residence of Abdul Kalam before launch of party
Untitled Page
Rashtra Deepika LTD
Copyright @ 2017 , Rashtra Deepika Ltd.