20
Friday
July 2018
8:03 PM IST
News Headlines
IOC adds 7 medal events to 2022 Beijing Winter Games program        Indian outplay New Zealand 4-2 in hockey series opener        Samsung, Xiaomi corner 60 pc share of India's smartphone mkt in Q2: Canalys        Indo-Pacific must be free, open and and inclusive region: Swaraj        Indian man shot dead in Canada, two suspects arrested        Trump says looking forward to 'second meeting' with Putin        Mob-lynching cases: Govt asks WhatsApp for solutions beyond labelling forwards        Unidentified 'intruder' killed at Indo-Pak border: official        Oppn, Govt brace for no-trust vote today; BJP confident of win, Cong says issue not just of numbers        Centre Forcing AgustaWestland Middleman To Frame Sonia Gandhi: Congress        We were clinical, says England captain Eoin Morgan        Growth has been solid, hope Olympiad will demonstrate it: Anand        Govt working on another verison of UDAN, says Sinha        Talks on between India, Singapore for cruise tourism: Gadkari        'Not too late to save Brexit': ex-foreign secretary Johnson        Canada: Trudeau set to reshuffle govt ahead of 2019 election        Woman alleges rape by Delhi-based singer        Opposition parties commit to fight against any amendment in RTI Act        Tharoor blames right-wing activists for attacks, demands PM intervention        Women have constitutional right to enter Sabarimala temple: SC        
Home   | Main News   | Kerala  | National   | International  | Business   | Sports   | Entertainment   | Columns   | Offbeat   | About Deepika 
Main News
Virtual revolt by 4 SC judges against CJI, say democracy at stake
 
(New Delhi, Jan 12, 2018):Warning that democracy is at stake, four senior judges of the Supreme Court on Friday mounted a virtual revolt against the country's chief justice, raising questions on "selective" case allocation and certain judicial orders, sending shockwaves across the judiciary and polity.

The unprecedented move by the four judges including Justice J Chelameswar, the second senior judge after Chief Justice Dipak Misra, brought to fore the simmering differences between the country's top judge and some senior judges in the apex court in recent months. The apex court currently has 25 judges

Justice Chelameswar himself described as an "extraordinary event" in the annals of the Indian judiciary when the judges addressed a joint news conference during which he said "sometimes administration of the Supreme Court is not in order and many things which are less than desirable have happened in the last few months."

The judge accused Justice Misra of not taking any "remedial measures" on some of the issues which affected the functioning of the apex court that they had raised. Justice Misra became the CJI on August 28, 2017 and he is due to retire from on October 2 this year

Unless this institution is preserved, "democracy will not survive" in this country, Justice Chelameswar said at the unscheduled press conference, in the first of its kind event in independent India, leaving uncertain how this open dissension in the hallowed institution would be resolved.

In a scathing criticism and unvarnished self-reflection of the Supreme Court, Chelameswar, who was accompanied by Justices Ranjan Gogoi, M B Lokur and Kurian Joseph at the press conference, said they had met the chief justice this morning and "raised issues affecting the institution." The CJI and the four judges comprise the Supreme Court collegium that selects judges for the higher judiciary

"Unless this institution is preserved, democracy will not survive in this country," Justice Chelameswar said, adding that it was "extremly painful" to hold the press conference in such a manner. The conference was held at his residence here

He said all the four judges "failed to persuade CJI that certain things are not in order and therefore you should take remedial measures. Unfortunately our efforts failed

"And all four of us are convinced that democracy is at stake and many things have happened in recent past," he said

Asked what these issues were, he said they included the "allocation of cases by CJI". The remarks assume significance as the apex court earlier in the day took up for consideration the issue of alleged mysterious death of special CBI judge B H Loya, who was hearing the sensitive Sohrabuddin Sheikh 'fake encounter' case

Justice Chelameswar said "we owe a responsibility to the institution and the nation. Our efforts have failed in convincing CJI to take steps to protect the institution."

"This is an extraordinary event in the history of any nation, more particularly this nation and an extraordinary event in the institution of judiciary ... It is with no pleasure that we are compelled to call this press conference."

There was no immediate official response from the CJI office.

Asked whether they wanted the Chief Justice to be impeached, Justice Chelameswar said, "let the nation decide."

The Centre made it clear it is not going to intervene on the unprecedented development, saying the judiciary will resolve the issue itself. "Our judiciary is reputed all over the world, independent and they will sort the matter themselves," said minister of state for law P P Chaudhury

The four judges, in their seven-page letter to the CJI, said, "It is with great anguish and concern that we have thought it proper to address this letter to you so as to highlight certain judicial orders passed by this court which has adversely affected the overall functioning of the justice delivering system and the independence of the high courts besides impacting the administrative functioning of the office of the Hon'ble Chief Justice of India."

The letter, that was released to the press, was sent a couple of months back, Justice Chelameswar said.

"It is too well settled in the jurisprudence of this country that the chief justice is only first amongst the equals -- nothing more or nothing less."

The letter said that there have been instances where cases having "far reaching consequences for the nation" and the institution have been assigned by the chief justices of this court "selectively to the benches 'of their preference' without any rationale basis" for such assignment. "This must be guarded against at all costs."



"We are not mentioning details only to avoid embarrassing the institution but note that such departures have already damaged the image of this institution to some extent."

The letter also raised the concerns of the judges on allocation of cases.

"It is too well settled in the jurisprudence of this country that the chief justice is only first amongst the equals -- nothing more or nothing less.

"A necessary corollary to the above mentioned principle is the members of any multi numbered judicial body including this court would not arrogate to themselves the authority to deal with and pronounce upon matters which ought to be heard by appropriate benches, both composition wise and strength wise with due regard to the roster fixed

"Any departure from the above two rules would not only lead to unpleasant and undesirable consequences of creating doubt in the body politic about the integrity of the institution. Not to talk about the chaos that would result from such departure

"We are sorry to say that off late the twin rules mentioned above have not been strictly adhered to," the letter said.

The legal fraternity said they were "pained" and "sad" at the outcome of events in the country's highest court.

"It is very unfortunate," said former CJI K G Balakrishnan, while Congress leader Ashwani Kumar, who is also a senior advocate, observed, "It is a sad day for the judicial system." Some senior advocates like K T S Tulsi said there could have been some "compelling" reasons for the four judges to lay bare their differences.

Attorney General K K Venugopal, who had a meeting with Justice Misra after the joint news conference of the judges, said it "could have been avoided" and that all judges would now have to act in "statesmanship" to ensure total harmony

At the news conference, the judges rubbished suggestions that they have broken ranks and said they will discharge their duties as usual

Justice Gogoi said "nobody is breaking the rank and it is discharge of debt to nation which we have done." Gogoi would be succeeding Misra as CJI in October this year.


Centre Forcing AgustaWestland Middleman To Frame Sonia Gandhi: Congress
Women have constitutional right to enter Sabarimala temple: SC
Court's duty to strike down law if it violates fundamental right: SC
Mamata govt runs syndicate raj, says Modi; TMC hits back
France clinches World Cup with win over Croatia
Social media hub like creating surveillance state: SC
Discrimination against gays will go if criminality of section 377 is removed: SC
Telecom Comm approves net neutrality, new telecom policy
All 12 boys and coach rescued from Thai cave
Samsung opens world's largest mobile phone factory in Noida
PNB's big wilful defaulters' dues fall to Rs 15,354 cr in June
Several Congress leaders are on bail, party is a 'bail gaadi': PM
Once again, Supreme Court upholds Chief Justice of India as 'Master of Roster'
Make match-fixing criminal offense: Law Commission of India
CM Kejriwal directs officers to speed up AAP govt projects after SC verdict
SC restrains States and UTs from appointing acting DGPs
India can play a major role in 'unstable world' to achieve peace: PM Modi
Russia beat Spain 4-3 on penalties to reach World Cup quarter-finals
Belgium beat England 1-0, face Japan in FIFA World Cup 2018 pre-quarters
Lashkar terrorist among three identified for involvement in Bukhari's killing: Police
KERALA NEWS
Kerala among 13 states on thunderstorm alert
 (New Delhi, May 7, 2018): Thunderstorms accompanied by squall, hail and heavy rains are likel  
Kerala Karshaka Jadha Opens to a Great Beginning / Video
Malappuram press club attack: RSS workers nabbed
Workers injured in mudslide at construction site
INTERNATIONAL NEWS
Indian man shot dead in Canada, two suspects arrested
 Toronto, Jul 19 (PTI) A 27-year-old Indian man was shot dead by four assailants in his home in Canad
Trump says looking forward to 'second meeting' with Putin
'Not too late to save Brexit': ex-foreign secretary Johnson
Canada: Trudeau set to reshuffle govt ahead of 2019 election
NATIONAL NEWS
Mob-lynching cases: Govt asks WhatsApp for solutions beyond labelling forwards
 New Delhi, Jul 19 (PTI) The government today shot off another notice to WhatsApp asking it to come o
Unidentified 'intruder' killed at Indo-Pak border: official
Oppn, Govt brace for no-trust vote today; BJP confident of win, Cong says issue not just of numbers
Woman alleges rape by Delhi-based singer
Untitled Page
Rashtra Deepika LTD
Copyright @ 2017 , Rashtra Deepika Ltd.