September 2018
11:50 PM IST
News Headlines
Home   | Main News   | Kerala  | National   | International  | Business   | Sports   | Entertainment   | Columns   | Offbeat   | Health   | About Deepika 
National News
Real power, accountability vests with elected representatives, not LG: SC
New Delhi, Jul 4 (PTI) The real power and "substantive" accountability in democratic system of governance vests with the elected representatives and not the Lieutenant Governor, Justice D Y Chandrachud said today.

"The LG must bear in mind that it is not he, but the council of ministers which takes substantive decisions and even when he invokes the proviso, the LG has to abide by the decision of the President," Justice Chandrachud said in a separate but concurring verdict on the power tussle between the LG and the Delhi government.

The Supreme Court judge, who wrote a 175-page order, said the Lieutenant Governor shall act on the aid and advise of the Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister.

The five-judge bench led by Chief Justice Dipak Misra laid down broad parameters for governance of the national capital, which has witnessed a bitter power tussle between the Centre and Delhi government since the Aam Aadmi Party came to power in 2014.

Justice Chandrachud said that under the Transaction of Business of the Government of NCT of Delhi Rules, 1993, the LG must be kept duly apprised on all matters pertaining to the administration of affairs of the NCT and the Rules indicate the duty of the Council of Ministers to inform the Lieutenant Governor right from the stage of a proposal before it.

He held that the provisions of Article 239 AA(4) must be operated and applied in a manner which facilitates and does not "obstruct" the governance in Delhi.

"While the provisions contained in the Transaction of Business Rules require a scrupulous observance of the duty imposed on the Council of Ministers to inform the Lieutenant Governor on all matters relating to the administration of the NCT, neither the provisions of Article 239AA, nor the provisions of the Act and Rules require the concurrence of the Lieutenant Governor to a decision which has been taken by the Council of Ministers," he said.

Justice Chandrachud said that the proviso to Article 239AA(4) must be operated and applied in a manner which facilitates and does not obstruct the governance of the National Capital Territory.

"If the expression 'any matter' were to be construed as 'every matter' or every trifling matter that would result in bringing to a standstill the administration of the affairs of the NCT. Every conceivable difference would be referred to the President. The elected representatives would be reduced to a cipher. The union government would govern the day- to-day affairs," he said.

The judge said that in discharging his constitutional role, the LG has to be conscious of the fact that the Council of Ministers which tenders aid and advice is elected to serve the people and represents both the aspirations and responsibilities of democracy.

Justice Chandrachud also clarified that in case of difference of opinion between the Lieutenant Governor and the council of ministers, "the Lieutenant Governor must, by a process of dialogue and discussion, seek to resolve any difference of opinion with a Minister and if it is not possible to have it so resolved to attempt it through the Council of Ministers.

"A reference to the President is contemplated by the Rules only when the above modalities fail to yield a solution, when the matter may be escalated to the President."

Justice Chandrachud also referred to the findings of the S Balakrishnan Committee founded in 1989 for making recommendations on the reorganization of structure for the governance of Delhi. Balakrishnan was an advisor in Ministry of Home Affairs.

The judge noted that the committee had opined that "the national capital belongs to the nation as a whole" and hence a demand for full statehood could not be entertained.

Instant Triple Talaq to be criminal offence
BJP, Congress mock Mamata's foreign visit
Three infants die every two minutes in India: UNIGME
'Sidhu could have avoided hugging Pak Army chief'
India's first IAS officer Anna Rajam Malhotra dies
'Launched Morcha for bringing change in UP, India'
ISRO to launch 18 missions in next six months
Jinson Johnson wins the prestigious Arjuna Award
Bank Officials Who Loaned To Vijay Mallya May Be Charged Soon: Sources
4,388 CCTV cameras installed across Delhi to ensure security of women, city police tells high court
Maharashtra court issues arrest warrant against AP CM, others
Stalin appoints T R Baalu as DMK principal secretary
Congress veteran D D Lapang quits party
ISRO Spy case: SC awards Rs 50 lakh compensation to Nambi Narayanan
Know What Does Percentile Score Stands for, in JEE Main
Six injured as bus rams into Army vehicle in Baramulla
Govt has brought a new work culture: PM
Suspected militants open fire on police personnel on J&K highway
57 Including Four Children Dead After Bus Falls Into Valley In Telangana
Hyderabad: Two arrested in Nizam’s Museum theft case; artefacts recovered
Viswasam- On set photos leaked
 A few photos from the set of Ajith's Viswasam is going viral on social media. The photos show Ajith  
Aiswarya- Abhishek's Gulab Jamun would go on floor in mid 2019
Varun and Anushka signed as ambassadors of Skill India Campaign
Madhuri, Alia, Varun and to share screen
100 die in severe flooding in Nigeria: relief agency
 Lokoja (Nigeria), Sep 18 (AFP) Nigeria has declared a national disaster after severe flooding left a
Pak govt, Opposition agree for parliamentary probe into vote rigging charges
Air Tanzania to soon resume direct flights to India
Imran Khan govt auctions 70 luxury cars as part of austerity drive
Bar bribery case: Court dismisses the vigilance report
 Thiruvananthapuram: The vigilance special court dismissed the report that absolved K.M. Mani from th
State Kalolsavam to be held in December
Actor Captain Raju passes away at 68
Hartal affected normal lives
Untitled Page
Rashtra Deepika LTD
Copyright @ 2018 , Rashtra Deepika Ltd.